Advertisement
Has anyone here discovered that, after reading comic books for a while, they get impatient trying to read novels? Such a situ makes me more selective in my novel choices now.
Most recent example: read the first issue of Elric: the Making of a Sorcerer by Moorcock and drawn by Simonson. Excited, I picked up Elric of Melnibone and started to read it. After a couple of pages, I thought, "would you move ON already?"
Most recent example: read the first issue of Elric: the Making of a Sorcerer by Moorcock and drawn by Simonson. Excited, I picked up Elric of Melnibone and started to read it. After a couple of pages, I thought, "would you move ON already?"
posted by:
|
|
Unsubscribed |
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: From reading comic books to novels
Mon, October 18, 2004 - 8:44 AMSounds like "Disney Syndrome" to me. All substance reduced to easily digestible pap.
-
Re: From reading comic books to novels
Mon, October 18, 2004 - 6:03 PMI am both a voracious comic and prose reader. The two media are barely comparable. Digesting good solid prose is a joy!
Exposition, and the ability to get into the head and world of a character is one of the hallmarks of straight prose, while comics, when used correctly, can use visual puns and non linear narratives with much more grace than the strict written word.
If you're reading a good prose novel, savor it, take your time, chances are it'll pay off.
And while there is a lot of "easily digestible pap" in the comic world, there is also a lot of really challenging stuff out there. -
-
Re: From reading comic books to novels
Mon, October 18, 2004 - 6:27 PMBut Joel's point was that after the comic, he couldn't read the prose. So how do you prioritise How you will be experiencing the story.
My analogy points to the millions of people from 0-50 who tried to read the Book after seeing the (Disney, mostly) movie and end up complaining that "it's not the Same!"
How many millions of kids who won't Finish Lord of the Rings because there's Different stuff in the books and it doesn't happen the same as the movie?
I wasn't Allowed to see Disney movies as a kid, and when i did, my complaint was "What the HELL did they do to the BOOK?"
Its great to be able to see somebody else's interpretation of a book or story- i own a couple of dozen versions of Alice in Wonderland for the different illustrations, but i only actually Read the Annotated Alice with the original Tenniel illustrations. Its important to understand the context of where the images came from, and in this case, the image is generated By the prose. And i do look at all the pictures! -
-
Unsu...
Re: From reading comic books to novels
Tue, October 19, 2004 - 6:43 AMI agree with Qatana, it was the same with me also, to go to a movie after reading the book. It is almost always a disappointment. There is no way a small\big screen can compare to the human imagination and if an author is good he\she can take you places and introduce you to people you couldn't get to any other way.
As for comic books....it just doesn't compare to a novel. They have great art and interesting stories, but --to me--they are like fast food. It is sad we are trained to always want it NOW and FAST or it isn't worth the time. I know some will disagree, but it is true.
-
Re: From reading comic books to novels
Fri, October 22, 2004 - 7:00 PMI completely agree. Movies are a medium separated from literature by sheer commercialism and the need to condense. Disney movies especially go out of their way to conform to some sort of strange societal 'norm'.
Most comic book movie adaptations are atrocious!
Comics as fast food; a good many of them are, I agree, but there is also a lot of fast food prose out there, just as there are also very challenging works in both media...
Check out authors like Alan Moore; notably The Watchmen (deconstruction of superheroes), Promethea (A kind of magical primer with a look at how magic effects out lives), V for Vendetta (a look at fascism which I might even say is timely)
Or LORE by Ashley Wood (IDW press) which mixes prose with comics and beautiful paintings.
Or even The Dark Knight Returns, by Frank Miller, which is a great, political "ending" to the Batman mythos.
Comics can be really easy to pass over because they're illustrated, but a good comic...a skilled illustrator and a skilled writer can turn a page of comics into a riddle that is just as challenging as a page of text to decipher.
My advice to Joel is to not approach these media as if they're the same. If you're going to read a book be prepared to work a little. Conversely, to those prose readers, try to approach a comic with the diligence you would approach a novel.
-
-
