What do you dislike about fantasy novels

topic posted Thu, April 16, 2009 - 1:05 AM by  nigel
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Over the years I have read an awful lot of books. I have read so many that I have enjoyed but quite a few that I haven't. I am beginning to develope an allorgic reaction to certain aspects of the genre. Things that really turn me off a book. Things that stop me pulling it off the shelf to read.
the review "compareable to Tolkien at his best" on the back cover
A map of the land
A glossary of terms at the back.

Is there anything that turns you off these books?
posted by:
nigel
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: What do you dislike about fantasy novels

    Fri, April 17, 2009 - 3:41 PM
    POOR WRITING!
    I've read plenty that have an excellent story (they have a fully developed, beautiful world), but their storytelling is so poor I couldn't stand pulling myself through to get to the end. And tragically, several of these authors have that "compareable to Tolkien at his best." SO untrue. Makes me sick.
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: What do you dislike about fantasy novels

    Sat, April 18, 2009 - 6:31 PM
    Fantasy and Sci-fi seem so close to me.

    I always disliked Space Opera.

    But there are good writers in every sub-genre.

    Like... Piers Anthony. One of the first authors I read.

    And I read just about every original Conan book that
    Rober E. Howard wrote. Those were damn good for a 14 year old.
    Though the English teacher didn't like me making book reports on them.

    Iguess she wanted me to be reading Jane Eyre, or something.
    Something romantic, all about the magic or eternal love.
    Nah, I thought. More like a massive ape on an island
    trying to crush Conan's sinewy neck...
  • Re: What do you dislike about fantasy novels

    Fri, April 24, 2009 - 1:06 AM
    Can I add the following types of title?

    "The somethng and the something" as in 'The Warlock and the Warthog' or 'The Wizard and the Lizard'

    or
    Titles in a series which are just the franchise name and a job
    The Warlords of Bong
    The Magicians of Bong

    or

    The hero and something

    Kongar the Barbarian
    Kongar the Pirate
    Kongar's Sword
    Kongar's Bannana

Recent topics in "fantasybooks"